• The Wrap Up
  • Posts
  • The Wrap Up Newsletter | Swipe Right on ROI for Valentine’s Day Marketing That Converts

The Wrap Up Newsletter | Swipe Right on ROI for Valentine’s Day Marketing That Converts

American Greetings is redefining digital gifting with songs, experiences, and even cash.

Author

Sophie Bruxner-Randall
February 13, 2025 • Estimated Reading Time: 8 minutes

Welcome to The Wrap Up, your weekly newsletter for gifting eCommerce professionals.

Sector Spotlight 🎥

DIGITAL GIFTING STRATEGY

American Greetings is redefining digital gifting through strategic partnerships with Virgin Experience Gifts, Songfinch, and Birdie, offering personalized songs, cash gifts, and experience-based presents. This expansion into hyper-personalized, digital-first gifting solutions highlights a key opportunity for eCommerce marketers: leveraging emotional engagement, frictionless transactions, and tech-driven personalization to enhance customer loyalty and drive conversions. As consumer expectations shift toward unique, memorable gifting experiences, brands that prioritize customization and seamless digital fulfillment will be best positioned for sustained growth in the gifting commerce space.

LUXURY GIFTING STRATEGY

Woodhouse Spas expertly optimize Valentine's Day as a pivotal revenue opportunity, employing strategies like couples services and value-added promotions, such as gift-with-purchase, to enhance market positioning. This approach, emphasizing emotional connections, aligns with personalization trends in eCommerce, driving not just immediate sales but also fostering sustained client loyalty. Such strategies resonate well within the luxury spa sector, offering actionable insights for digital marketers focusing on innovative gifting solutions.

The support from Woodhouse Spas' corporate structure is crucial, providing franchisees with comprehensive marketing assets and campaign frameworks to streamline operations. These tools facilitate efficient resource allocation—vital in eCommerce and retail—ensuring inventory and staffing align with peak demand periods. By adopting these strategic models, franchises not only maintain cohesive branding across locations but also reduce promotional expenses while driving consistent revenue growth. Through this targeted approach, Woodhouse Spas not only secures short-term financial gains but also builds a robust foundation for long-term customer engagement and market expansion, offering valuable strategies for eCommerce leaders focused on growing their gifting commerce.

ECOMMERCE GIFTING INSIGHTS

Valentines Day Love GIF by Bryson Williams

Gif by artofbryson on Giphy

Valentine's Day emerges as a strategic gem for eCommerce, blending gifting traditions with vast commercial opportunities. During this retail bonanza, consumers flock to shops for everything from tech gadgets to customized gifts. Tapping into the nuances of societal expectations and purchasing behaviors is essential for eCommerce leaders aiming to optimize marketing strategies and customer experiences. The holiday, despite its critics, thrives on America's affection for grand gestures, demanding sophisticated strategies in gifting commerce.

For eCommerce professionals, aligning products with the Valentine's ethos is critical. Brands like Tiffany and Co. exemplify the power of personalized offerings, while advanced retargeting strategies tackle the significant 76% abandonment rate in digital carts. This challenge and opportunity dynamic is pivotal in converting casual browsers into decisive buyers, highlighting operational efficiency and strategic insight.

Expanding the Valentine’s Day appeal beyond traditional romance can capture new demographics, like those reveling in self-love. Innovative eCommerce campaigns can introduce exclusive products tailored for singles, demonstrating how strategic personalization transcends standard romance and boosts consumer engagement. This reflects a broader opportunity for eCommerce professionals: leveraging the complexities of love into data-driven, personalized shopping experiences that not only meet but anticipate consumer needs.

GIFTING SOLUTIONS

Toasty Card is reshaping corporate gifting with a personalized, AI-enhanced, and sustainability-focused approach, aligning with global eCommerce trends. By prioritizing eco-friendly rewards and seamless digital fulfillment, the brand showcases how automation and customization can enhance operational efficiency and customer engagement.

For eCommerce marketers, this shift underscores the growing demand for scalable, data-driven gifting solutions that boost loyalty, streamline logistics, and create meaningful brand touchpoints in an increasingly competitive market.


MARKET TRENDS

The January Dallas Home & Gift Market saw record-breaking attendance, reinforcing its position as a key hub for buyer engagement and strategic growth despite winter weather challenges. Industry leaders praised the strong order volumes and showroom innovation, signaling continued momentum for brands and retailers. For eCommerce and performance marketers in the gifting space, this surge highlights growing demand for curated, high-quality products and the importance of omnichannel strategies to capitalize on shifting consumer trends.

Influencer Corner 📣

Lara Acosta on LinkedIn: My most important personal brand rule: tell your story.

People don’t just buy products—they buy from people they relate to or aspire to be like. That’s why storytelling isn’t just a personal brand strategy—it’s a playbook for businesses too.
Educational content earns trust, but stories of transformation, lessons, and values build connection. Consumers care about what a brand stands for, not just what it sells.
Brand story is your differentiator, and tell it.

James Gray on LinkedIn: Content is both a superpower and a stressor.

For most brands, Content is both a superpower and a stressor. It fuels brand awareness, customer engagement, and revenue growth, but managing it at scale? That’s another story entirely! 🤯 (...one which Ian MacArthur and I went into in more detail in the full article on the Remarkable website)...

Between siloed teams, duplicated efforts, and the ever-growing pressure to be faster, smarter, and more engaging, many organisations find themselves drowning in content chaos. And with AI now in the mix, the challenge isn’t just about keeping up, it’s about balancing automation with authenticity.

Performance Pulse 📈

MARKETING CAMPAIGNS

Valentine’s Day marketing isn’t what it used to be. This year, brands ditched clichés and delivered campaigns that sparked conversations—some through cultural influence, others by flipping the holiday on its head.

From SKIMS tapping into the power of fandoms to LEGO redefining Valentine’s gifting, and even brands like Publix celebrating love beyond romance, these campaigns prove that standing out requires more than heart-shaped products.

ClickZ breaks down the smartest Valentine’s Day strategies, including the rise of Anti-Valentine’s campaigns and last-minute marketing tactics that still drive results. Which brands nailed it? Let’s dive in.

DIGITAL CREATOR STRATEGIES

Brands are leveraging episodic partnerships with creators to target younger audiences effectively. These long-term collaborations enable cost efficiencies, consistent content, and sustained engagement. By integrating creators into series, marketers enhance storytelling and audience connection, ensuring strategic advantages over one-off posts.


DIGITAL MARKETING

Focus drives impact in 2025 marketing, with key channels like SEO, events, social media, and paid search leading. Reduce low-impact tactics, emphasize high-ROI programs. AI use is growing but must be strategic. Align GTM goals with pipeline creation, not MQLs, for effective marketing leadership.

Social Media Marketing

📍 Seattle, Washington, USA

Marketing & Comms

 📍 Austin, TX, USA

ClickZ is a Contentive publication in the DTC eCommerce division